I have messaged Dave Portnoy multiple times about coming to Salernos. In my not so humble opinion, it is the best grandma’s pie in New Jersey- hands down. Honorable mention goes to their buffalo chicken pie that could feed a family of 10 - that's how big the chicken pieces are on it. A third favorite of mine here is their “tie-dye” pie which has marinara, pesto, and vodka sauce on a grandma’s pie. Warning for that though, you need to order a full pie and cannot purchase by the slice!